Smashing Pumpkins
Machina/The Machines of God (Virgin)
Oasis
Ratings - Machina/The Machines of God: 5/Standing on the Shoulder of Giants: 5
Standing on the Shoulder of Giants (Sony/Epic)
When it's done correctly, there is nothing more beautiful than a big,
grandiose rock album. Of course, the ego which accompanies such bombast
is always as detrimental as it is necessary. Sadly, the inevitable
conclusion to a sky-high ego is a crushing return to earth.
Consider the strange career of [Smashing Pumpkins/Oasis], a band who
made a great case for big-rock production with their breakthrough
album [Siamese Dream/Definitely Maybe], released at a time when
"hip" meant singing half-songs into a fuzzy four-track. They
took their art even further with their next album, 1995's
[Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness/(What's the Story) Morning Glory?],
but it hasn't been the same for [Smashing Pumpkins/Oasis] since that
landmark dropped. Inter-band turmoil, drug problems, and a lousy follow-up
album later, [Billy Corgan/Noel Gallagher] finds himself in a strange
new position: having to prove himself all over again.
With his band's new album, [Machina/The Machines of God/Standing on the Shoulder of Giants],
he finds himself partially on the road to recovery. The album, a
thick stew of tight power chords and desperate riffs, is an intentional
and unabashed return to what made this band so popular in the first
place. There are moments worthy of their '95 peak - ["Try, Try, Try"/"Who Feels Love?"],
for example, is splendid psychadelia, dreamy but with a satisfying
crunch. There are some absolutely terrible songs on the record, however
, with the worst offender being ["I of the Mourning"/"Little James"],
which combines remarkably stupid lyrics with nothing melodies. The
other songs are neither as great nor as terrible as these two, which
is fortunate: Coming off a terrible album, this consistently mediocre
record is unquestionably a step, if not a leap, towards past glories.
- Matt Bell
your
shot
Think you can do better? Email us your pithy comments on the
cd's and shows we
review, and the lists and essays we write.
We'll publish excerpts in future editions...