Elastica:
The Menace (Atlantic)

Encumbered by an over-praised debut, myriad songwriting controversies, drug rumors, intra-band friction and a muscular, guitar-heavy sound in the age of melodic wimp-pop, Elastica ironically find themselves staring down a backlash --or worse still, complete indifference --right when their long-delayed, much-improved sophomore effort should be establishing them as rightful heirs to the Television-Wire-Voidoids estate. Sure, The Menace made my shopping list thanks to a lull in the new-release parade --the band's good-not-great self-titled introduction didn't catapult them to must-buy status --but its tenure in my CD player isn't an accident of timing. Justine Frischmann's ship of gold may have sailed without her, but her muse apparently opted to stick with her on the dock.

Fans who managed to keep the faith during Elastica's five-year intermission will probably recognize at least some of the tracks here --about half appeared in EP versions recorded by a different line-up. But I'm not, or at least wasn't, among the faithful, and I'm surprised how unified The Menace's 13 tracks sound, and how remarkably well half-a-decade's worth of material hangs together. Obviously, Frischmann's tenure as the "It"girl of the parochial and cannibalistic UK pop scene hasn't dimmed her cool wit or her cocky intelligence; if anything, it's spurred her to up the ante.

Unlike Elastica's hook-dropping manipulations, The Menace is far more convincing in assimilating its influences. But anyone living and listening in the new century who can convince themselves that Pink Flag is recyclable material at least as valuable as Pink Moon will find plenty of pearls scattered about: the album's opening triptych --"Mad Dog God Dam," "Generator" and "How He Wrote Elastica Man" are tight, deliciously aggressive shards of postpunk discord, "Human" and "Nothing Stays the Same" are ethereal slow-burns, "Da Da Da" proves a cheeky toss-off that cuts off any hints of pretension at the knees.

Of course, plumming the depths of the late-70s songbook, however impressively, doesn't earn you points with the fashion police. In a typical dis, one quick-witted mouth-breather posited that Elastica garners so much critical attention because they're "fronted by a woman" (someone tell that to Sarge, Le Tigre or Amy Rigby). That kind of myopic, silly-assed reasoning is why, after her moment in the sun, Justine Frischmann is probably doomed to popular irrelevance, even on these shores. And it's why The Menace already looks like a secret gem, fresh from the shrink-wrap.


Rating: 8
- Rob Brookman

 

your shot
Think you can do better? Email us your pithy comments on the cd's and shows we review, and the lists and essays we write. We'll publish excerpts in future editions...

review archive

front page